Skip to main content

DESMA 9 Week 6



Biotechnology has always been an extremely controversial field, especially since the damning documentary entitled “The World According to Monsanto” which highlighted the dangers of using biotechnology. One example of biotechnology gone wrong would be the genetically modified(GMO) wheat, produced by Monsanto. The “super crop” is now a pest in many farms in the United States, since its genetically modified resistance makes the plant hard to kill. Another example would be the bovine growth hormone which Monsanto injected into cows to increase milk production. Unfortunately, this resulted in horrific side effects, like pus growing in the udders of cows. Said pus is then found in the milk produced by the cows. More importantly, due to the udders becoming more susceptible to infection, cows injected with the hormone end up dying. Given the above, it was interesting and yet deeply disturbing for me to learn that artists are dabbling into biotechnology.
Side effect of the growth hormone used by Monsanto
In my opinion, the genetic code of any species should not be modified till the effect of said modification is fully researched. Anyone involved, regardless of profession, should be equally responsible and careful when messing around with genetic code, especially given its ramifications. Like how only surgeons should perform operations, I believe that only dedicated scientist should have the ability to alter genetic code. Testimony to my opinion would be Martha Diminezas’s art work, where she altered the wing patterns of butterflies. As a result, the modified butterflies were found to have holes in their wings, which spelt certain death if they were released into the wild. Thankfully, to our knowledge the altered butterflies were contained in the lab. Should this destructive gene be released into the wild, it would cause a mass extinction of butterflies.
Patterns on the wings of butterflies vary even within the same species
However, that is not to say I do not support the genetic modification of animals. While it may seem hypocritical to support lab work including genetically modified mice, the crux is to understand the purpose of said animal. Most of the lab grown mice are made to stand in for humans in drug test or other life threatening test. Conversely, the butterflies were, at best, made to make a statement. Even if it was to raise awareness of cruelty against lab animals, this would be an extremely ironic and roundabout way to do so. Following in the footsteps of Kathy High, where she adopted and cared for lab grown mice, would be a much better approach to raising awareness. Given the examples mentioned in the lecture, it feels like most artist dabbling in this field seem to be merely capitalizing on biotechnology’s sensationalism in order to increase their own exposure.
One of the lab grown rats adopted by Kathy High for her exhibition
In conclusion, it is my opinion biotechnology should be considered sacred ground and not an opportunity to expand one’s repertoire. While limitless human creativity is a good thing, it also pays to tread lightly when messing around with genetic code, given the severe repercussions it may have on humanity’s well-being. Therefore, laws should keep up with technology before it is too late, as it is with global warming.

Source:
"The World According to Monsanto." DocumentaryHeaven. N.p., n.d. Web. 06 May 2017. <http://documentaryheaven.com/the-world-according-to-monsanto/>.
Lorraine_chow. "Monsanto's Unapproved GMO Wheat Found Growing in Washington State." EcoWatch. EcoWatch, 02 Aug. 2016. Web. 06 May 2017. <http://www.ecowatch.com/monsantos-unapproved-gmo-wheat-growing-washington-1954609745.html>.
Bovine Growth Hormone: Milk does nobody good... N.p., n.d. Web. 06 May 2017. <http://www.ejnet.org/bgh/nogood.html>.
"Laboratory mouse." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 03 May 2017. Web. 06 May 2017. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laboratory_mouse>.
Vesna, Victoria. "5 BioArt Pt2." YouTube. YouTube, 17 May 2012. Web. 06 May 2017.<https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PL9DBF43664EAC8BC7&v=MdSt-Hjyi2I>

 

Comments

  1. UnknownMay 17, 2017 at 10:55 PM

    I really enjoyed seeing a point of view that differed from mine. I understand better the cons to what I believed, especially when you pointed out things like the fact that not everyone would be as responsible as necessary, and it could lead to really negative results, like the deaths of the butterflies from holes in their wings. Overall, I really liked reading your blog!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

DESMA 9 Week 3

Growing up, I developed an interest in robots. To me they were smart, immortal, and efficient beings capable of great feats of strength and intelligence. Movies such as The Iron Giant, and the entire Star Wars franchise further reinforced my perception of robots. This love for robotics lead me to read books written by the great science fiction writer, Arthur C. Clarke. Arthur C. Clarke's Most Iconic Work Hence, I was unsurprised to learn that the modern concept for robots was inspired by a play written by a Czech writer, Karel Capek. In many ways, Sir Clarke had a similar impact on the scientific world as Mr Capek. An apt example would be the artificial intelligence computer named HAL 9000, in Sir Clarke’s book entitled “2001: A Space Odyssey”. In the book and the similarly named movie, HAL 9000 is an on-board computer for a spacecraft, responsible for maintaining ship functions and to act as a companion for human crew. However, due to a series of events, HAL malfunction...
2 comments
Read more

DESMA 9 Week 9

My father has always enjoyed the concept of space travel and was the reason he became an aerospace engineer. Hence, I grew up watching science fiction films like “Star Wars” and “Star Trek”, just to name a popular few. Unsurprisingly, this led me to read books by Arthur C. Clarke and Jules Verne. All the above fuelled my interest in space and technology, in fact one of the reasons I choose mechanical engineering as a major is due to a childish dream to build a lightsabre. Therefore, it is safe to say art plays a huge role in inspiring advancements in science. Movie Poster for R.U.R. In truth, there are many examples of how art propelled science to greater heights, many of which have been mentioned throughout this course. The most prominent example would be robots, which was the subject of the lecture in week 3. The term robot was first coined by a Czech writer, Karel Capek, as the subject of his play entitled R.U.R., which explored what happened when sentinel robots were use...
1 comment
Read more